Jubilee? No thank you Mam!

I don’t think I’d be overstating it to say that I hated every minute of the Queen’s Diamond Jubilee. To anyone who knows me this might not be news; hate is a very strong word for me and I don’t use it lightly.

But let me stop you there. I don’t think of myself as a republican, tending to agree with the idea that the word has been hijacked by fruitcake right-wing head bangers in the US. I’m not really in favour of strongly centralised state governments either, making me somewhere between an Anarchist (though I vote, so that’s inaccurate) and a progressive Socialist, which is probably more like it.

It’s just that I revile state sponsored jollity, carefully engineered by the mass media to make you feel like a freak if you don’t want to join in. Unlike some of my silly bastard near neighbours I didn’t attend a street party either. Theirs was brightly festooned with union flags, giving the whole event an air of wartime austerity. ‘We might be counting the pennies but we still know how to scoff fairy cakes and drink lemonade.’

And that’s just it. I’ve never had much respect for crowd driven behaviour, believing that it smacks of desperation. Such things strip the epidermis off our nation, revealing that beneath the surface the English have never completely abandoned their propensity for a bit of mass boot-licking and social deference.

‘The Queen does a great job,’ I heard someone say – and ‘It must be lonely.’ Gosh, she was even bombed out of house and home during the war. I don’t know whether to swoon with admiration or doff my cap. By way of comment my elderly mum had to shelter under the stairs while Germans tried to murder her; but society doesn’t give a rats about her. They should; she’s a woman of great courage. And she doesn’t have any ladies in waiting to help her care for my sick father.

I didn’t strut my stuff at any Jubilee parties, but I found it hard to escape from the relentless media bombardment. Whenever I switched on the radio I was subjected to endless gushing tributes to ‘Her Maj.’ The subtext to the whole event was, ‘We’re going to force you to listen to this if it kills us.’

When I went outside for a walk around, the media volume cranked up to the max. Oh look, there’s Kylie on our big screen in the city centre. Wow, she’s rocking to the jagged beat of the nation’s collective heartbeat. What a pity that her act looked like an advert for breakfast cereal.

Naturally there’s nothing wrong with parties or celebrations, but it puzzles me why anyone would want to pop a cork in honour of someone they don’t know. Someone who inherited her ‘job’ whether she liked it or not (part of her terrible burden, gawd bless ‘er) and who, in my view, should have absolutely nothing to do with modern democracy.

I made no friends this weekend after my extended Jubilee tirade, but I have zero regrets for having spoken out. I dislike the monarchy and all it represents. But equally I dislike people who refuse to critique it. In a sense, I feel they’ve rolled over and died. Accepted their free lobotomy.

There seems to be a woolly national consensus along the lines of: ‘well, it might be crap but anything we replace it with would be even crapper!’ God, what a nihilistic viewpoint! A quick reading of the UK’s social history reveals that progressives managed to reform the state to at least make it more accommodating. Of course no self respecting Anarchist would accept a concept like that, preferring to abolish the state altogether. It’s a tempting idea…

Progressive ideals, translated into legislation through political struggle, explain why we no longer ship people off to workhouses. In fact one of my ancestors ended up in one and he probably didn’t survive the experience. It’s why most children can read and write; though frankly literacy levels are shockingly bad in many parts of the UK.

In fact there’s a long list of positive reforms which are still possible, and which I – as a very convinced Socialist – want to see implemented.

But the institution of monarchy has no interest in advancing such ‘naive’ notions, and since it isn’t part of the cure it has no place in 21st Century Britain.  I understand the opposing arguments: the Royal Family generates money through tourism. They bring us hope, pageantry and a sense of occasion. Thank you, but there are other ways to generate income – and, in case you are interested – if we removed the Royal Family we could release billions of £s to help us pay off our national debt.

I want the state to release its grip on the lives on ordinary people, and if you’re having a street party please invite me. Just don’t, I beg of you, mention the Queen.


4 thoughts on “Jubilee? No thank you Mam!

  1. A coherent and persuasive post. I fully agree, but lacked the willpower to pursue the issue on a certain other forum when faced with others who weren’t willing or able to engage with the issue. I find it a shame that others felt the need to resort to wilful and patronising misrepresentation of the arguments of anyone who expressed a distaste for jubilee/monarchy.

    Like you, I enjoy a good street party as much as anyone, but find the brown-nosing and conformity attached to such royal occasions to be rather distasteful (to put it mildly), and, indeed, conceptually, far removed from any historical (and prehistorical) form of collective joy from Dionysian rituals and Beltane to medieval carnival and Woodstock. Jubilee is the commodification of collective experience for the promotion of conservative values.

    Anyway, the acid rain has now dissolved the bunting. The masses have halted the genuflection, and returned to the usual hating.

    Keep up the good work.

  2. Thank you Mr S Puppet! That is easily the best blog comment I’ve ever had insofar as I really enjoyed reading it. Not just because I feel vindicated (which I suppose is just my ego talking) but because it’s well written. I appreciate what you’ve said because the comments you’re referring to were a very deliberate attempt to provoke me. I feel extremely disappointed about that.

    And certainly, some forumites were intensely patronising about this issue. I don’t blame anyone for staying away from the ‘debate’; but I think I understand that some people want me to fall silent.

    • I don’t think many would want you to fall silent, because your thoughts on the matter are just as coherent and persuasive as Mr Puppet suggests. For my part, FWIW, I have reached a state of heightened cynicism that means I find it difficult to get enthusiastic about any political system; the corollary to that is that I find it difficult to attack any det of ideas which seem to me to be little more than just one daft idea amongst many.

      I admire your fire and power. Keep musing bohemianly my friend 🙂

      • Thanks Mr Livered – sorry I took ages to reply to this: I’ve not really been reading my emails lately! I see your point and thanks for making it. I certainly felt that way at the time (like I was being shot at simply for expressing my views), but I think I’ve simmered down a bit now! The Jubilee was awful for me as I couldn’t engage with it. I couldn’t escape from it either, and I felt angry about that.

        I suspect a lot of people feel the same as you, but I think the reason such things persist is because too many people have disengaged from the debate… Oh well, I don’t suppose the Queen will evaporate overnight because of my blog article! 😉

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s